Follow a former soldier’s journey from worldly allegiance to wholehearted devotion to Christ. Hear early church and Anabaptist testimonies and a call to bold non-resistance.

This course is free to access. The Historic Faith is donation-funded, with no paywall and no subscription required. Generous supporters help keep these lessons open to anyone in the world.
Free Audiobook Guide

What This Free Course Covers

A Change of Allegiance is a free audiobook following Dean Taylor’s journey from military service to a conviction that allegiance to Christ must govern even questions of war, enemies, citizenship, and self-defense. The lessons move between personal testimony, biblical reflection, and historical examples.

Taylor begins with his own struggle as a soldier in Germany, including his request for conscientious objector discharge, then turns to the words of Jesus, the Old and New Testaments, early Christian writers, Constantine, Augustine, Anabaptist martyrs, and the two-kingdoms question. The later chapters press the subject inward: excuses, family fears, trust in God as defender, martyrdom, and the danger of centering on a cause rather than on Christ Himself.

The appendix gives practical counsel for those facing Selective Service or conscientious objection applications, while urging a respectful and law-abiding Christian witness.

Allegiance to Christ Christian non-resistance Love of enemies Two kingdoms Early church witness Anabaptist martyrdom Conscientious objection Spiritual warfare The cross and suffering Church and state

What You Will Study

  • Dean Taylor’s personal account of seeking conscientious objector discharge while serving in the army
  • A close wrestling with Jesus’ commands to love enemies, turn the other cheek, and refuse revenge
  • The question of how Old Testament wars relate to the New Testament teaching and example of Christ
  • Early Christian testimony on non-resistance, military service, persecution, prayer, and martyrdom
  • Taylor’s critique of Augustine’s just war reasoning and the church-state changes associated with Constantine
  • Anabaptist examples of enemy love, suffering, and faithfulness under persecution
  • The two-kingdoms framework, including Romans 13, submission to government, and higher allegiance to God
  • Practical guidance for Selective Service registration and conscientious objector applications

Questions This Course Helps Answer

  • Why did a soldier begin questioning whether a Christian could participate in war?
  • What did Matthew 5 and Jesus’ words about enemies mean to Taylor in the army?
  • How does the book approach the apparent tension between Old Testament warfare and New Testament non-resistance?
  • What did Taylor find in early Christian writings about war, violence, and enemy love?
  • How does the book explain the shift from a persecuted church to a church joined with imperial power?
  • Why does Taylor see Constantine and Augustine as important turning points in church history?
  • What examples from Anabaptist history encouraged Taylor and his wife?
  • How does the book distinguish the kingdom of God from the kingdoms of this world?
  • What does Romans 13 require, and what does it not require, in Taylor’s reading?
  • How should a Christian think about family protection, self-defense, and trusting God?
  • Why does the book connect non-resistance with the cross, martyrdom, and spiritual warfare?
  • How can someone document conscientious objection convictions before a draft or military hearing?

Lesson-by-Lesson Guide

Forward

The forward frames the book as Taylor’s testimony of leaving worldly allegiance for devotion to Christ. He introduces the purpose of the book: not merely to argue for non-resistance, but to call readers to hear and obey Jesus’ words.

  • What kind of journey does this audiobook describe?
  • Why does Taylor connect non-resistance with allegiance to Christ?
  • What role do early church and Anabaptist testimonies play in the book?

Chapter 1, Walking on dry ground

Taylor recounts presenting a request for conscientious objector discharge and describes the fears surrounding that step. He also traces earlier patriotic assumptions and the first serious confrontation with Jesus’ words in Matthew 5.

  • What led Taylor to request conscientious objector discharge?
  • How did Matthew 5 challenge his military service?
  • Why was patriotism such a difficult assumption for him to question?

Chapter 2, What changed

This chapter reflects on the fall of the Berlin Wall and Taylor’s realization that political decisions could quickly turn enemies into allies. He begins asking whether Christian love should be governed by human borders and national commands.

  • What did the fall of the Berlin Wall make Taylor question?
  • Can an enemy become a friend simply because political leaders say so?
  • How does the book connect patriotism with the search for God’s kingdom?

Chapter 3, Something went terribly wrong

Taylor turns to Augustine, the Donatists, and the development of just war reasoning, arguing that the church’s use of state power marked a serious departure. He also compares historical religious violence with his own military formation and asks how Christians should handle Old Testament war texts.

  • Why does Taylor see Augustine’s just war theory as a turning point?
  • How did church and state power become connected in this chapter’s account?
  • Why do Old Testament wars become a major question for non-resistance?

Chapter 4, The God of the Bible

Taylor wrestles with the God of the Old Testament, the commands and wars found there, and the New Testament teaching of Jesus. He argues that God’s character did not change, but that the battle plan for God’s people changed in Christ.

  • How does Taylor approach the wars of the Old Testament?
  • Does the book present God as changing between the Old and New Testaments?
  • What does it mean that Jesus disarmed Peter?

Chapter 5, The Early Church

Taylor describes his search in early Christian writings while the Gulf War approached. He cites early voices such as Tertullian, Clement of Alexandria, and Origen as witnesses to enemy love, prayer, and refusal to fight.

  • What did Taylor find in early Christian writings about war?
  • How did early Christians understand Jesus’ command to love enemies?
  • What kind of warfare did early Christian teachers emphasize?

Chapter 6, The Constantine Bridge

This chapter examines Constantine’s influence on the church’s political standing, theology, and relationship to imperial power. Taylor presents Constantine as a bridge between the persecuted church and the powerful church of later centuries.

  • Why is Constantine so important in Taylor’s account of church history?
  • How did imperial favor affect the church’s identity?
  • What questions does this raise about the kingdom of God and worldly power?

Chapter 7 : From Samurai to Sanctuary: Xavier's Mission in Japan

Taylor begins with Francis Xavier’s mission in Japan and the later suffering of Japanese Christians, then turns to the deeper question of why wars and fighting arise. He uses James and biblical examples to contrast human means with trust in God.

  • What does the story of Christianity in Japan illustrate for Taylor?
  • How does James answer the question of where wars come from?
  • Why does Taylor warn against using human means to accomplish God’s promises?

Chapter 8, Excuses

Taylor addresses common objections and hypothetical scenarios, especially questions about protecting family. He argues that obedience to Christ cannot be set aside by fear, consequences, or arguments built away from Scripture.

  • What kinds of excuses does Taylor hear when discussing non-resistance?
  • How does he answer questions about protecting one’s family?
  • Why does he emphasize building on the words of Jesus?

Chapter 9, The Pilgrim Church

Taylor describes the loneliness of questioning war in a military church setting and then finds encouragement in the wider pilgrim church. The chapter highlights Anabaptist figures and martyrs, including Menno Simons and Dirk Willems.

  • Why did Taylor and his wife feel like pilgrims?
  • How did Anabaptist testimonies encourage them?
  • What does the story of Dirk Willems show about enemy love?

Chapter 10, The Two Kingdoms

Taylor explains the two-kingdoms framework through his conscientious objector process and biblical passages about Caesar, God, and Jesus’ kingdom. He emphasizes respect for earthly authorities while locating ultimate allegiance in Christ’s kingdom.

  • What does Taylor mean by the two kingdoms?
  • How should Christians distinguish what belongs to Caesar from what belongs to God?
  • Why does Jesus’ statement, “My kingdom is not of this world,” matter here?

Chapter 11, Romans 13

This chapter studies Romans 13 as a test of biblical non-resistance and submission to government. Taylor distinguishes between government being ordained by God and government being blessed in all it does, while urging obedience where it does not contradict God.

  • How does Romans 13 fit with Christian non-resistance?
  • What obedience does Taylor believe Christians owe to government?
  • What is the difference between being ordained by God and being blessed by God?

Chapter 12, My Defender is God

Taylor reflects on childhood lessons about strength and then contrasts worldly defense with trusting God. He argues that non-resistance is not passivity, but requires spiritual weapons such as prayer, fasting, faith, and gospel witness.

  • What does Taylor mean when he says God is his defender?
  • How is non-resistance different from passivity?
  • What spiritual weapons does the chapter emphasize?

Chapter 13, The Theology of Martyrdom

Taylor presents the cross as the central weapon of Christian warfare and reflects on suffering, persecution, and martyrdom. He connects Jesus’ image of sheep among wolves with Paul’s teaching that believers are more than conquerors through Christ.

  • Why does Taylor call the cross the Christian’s ultimate weapon?
  • How can suffering and martyrdom be connected with victory?
  • How does the chapter apply non-resistance beyond war?

Chapter 14, Him or It

Taylor recounts the final conscientious objector hearing and the later approval of the discharge request. He also warns that peace or non-resistance can become an isolated cause unless Christ Himself remains the center.

  • What happened during Taylor’s conscientious objector hearing?
  • Why does he distinguish wanting Christ from merely wanting a cause?
  • How did the hearing become a witness to others?

Chapter 15, Alter Call

The closing chapter calls listeners to hear Jesus’ voice, repent, believe the gospel of the kingdom, and give Him full allegiance. Taylor applies the book’s message personally, asking whether the listener’s loyalty belongs to Christ or to the world’s values and weapons.

  • What does it mean to hear Jesus’ voice today?
  • Why does Taylor describe Jesus’ kingdom as a revolution of self-denial and love?
  • To whom does the listener give allegiance?

Navigating Conscientious Objection with Faith

This appendix gives practical counsel for young men facing Selective Service questions and for military members considering conscientious objector applications. Taylor stresses documentation, sincerity, lawful process, prayer, and a respectful Christian witness.

  • What should someone consider when registering with Selective Service?
  • How can conscientious objection convictions be documented before a crisis?
  • What steps does Taylor list for applying for conscientious objector status?

About the Book

Cover of A Change of Allegiance by Dean Taylor

One soldier's journey from the U.S. Army to Christian nonresistance

  • Author: Dean Taylor
  • First published: 2008
  • Publisher: Radical Reformation Books / Scroll Publishing Co.
  • Pages: 224
  • Audiobook length: ~6 hours
  • ISBN: 9780981897301

What should a Christian do with Jesus' words, 'Love your enemies'? Is it all right for a Christian to go to war? Doesn't a Christian have an obligation to defend his country? Dean Taylor and his wife Tania were both in the U.S. Army when they realized that, as committed Christians, they had to come to grips with these questions in a new and sincere quest for truth.

They were determined to follow Jesus Christ under the banner of no compromise. As they began to search the Scriptures and church history, they came to the startling discovery that the Christian Church originally was uniformly opposed to Christians going to war or joining the military.

In A Change of Allegiance, Taylor takes the reader on a moving journey through the Scriptures, Christian history, and his own life's story — demonstrating the incompatibility of Christianity and war. Ultimately, Taylor challenges the reader to consider where their allegiance really lies.

About the author: Dean Taylor and his wife Tania were both serving in the U.S. Army when, through study of Scripture and early church history, they came to the conviction that committed Christians cannot participate in war. Dean is the president of Sattler College in Boston, an Anabaptist minister, and a frequent speaker on Kingdom Christianity.

Praise from Readers

What readers and reviewers have said about A Change of Allegiance. These are short, attributed quotes from public reviews on Goodreads, Amazon, the publisher's site, and independent book reviewers.

There are a number of books available on the subject of nonresistance, but A Change of Allegiance by Dean Taylor is one of the best I've ever read. One of the things that makes this book unique is that it is written from the conviction of a man who came to that conviction from reading Scripture.

Editorial review, Amazon editorial review

An intriguing and eye-opening account of one couple's journey from the military to the full realization of the meaning behind Jesus's words 'love your enemies'.

Taneil, Goodreads review

This book has a powerful message. Are we willing to die for Christ and His Kingdom?

Kathryn Judson, Goodreads review

Solid read. I enjoyed the way Dean Taylor shared his personal journey to nonresistance and combined it with well-researched Scripture and history.

Nathan Weaver, Goodreads review

Much of A Change of Allegiance reads like an exciting novel — but it articulates correctly the true Christian's part in worldly wars. Lots of truth.

Audible listener, Audible review

External reader ratings: Goodreads 4.38/5 (94 ratings) · Amazon 4.50/5 (31 ratings)
External ratings are shown for context only and are not used in the on-site review score above. Site reviews come exclusively from registered students.

Be the first to review this course

No reviews yet on this course. If this teaching has been a blessing to you, a short review is one of the most powerful ways to help others find it — honest reviews help this course rank higher in Google so more people discover the historic faith.

Help spread the message. Every honest review helps more people discover this teaching through Google and word of mouth. If this course has helped you, sharing a few sentences is one of the simplest ways to support the mission — it’s free, takes about a minute, and reaches people we may never meet.
A Change of Allegiance

Preview this Course

+38 enrolled
Start Course

Open Registration

Course Includes

  • 17 Lessons
  • 17 Quizzes
  • Course Certificate